With two young kids in my house, I’ve found that Halloween is easily my favorite holiday at the moment. I’m generally not ever looking to make holiday-themed golf content, but my enjoyment of Halloween combined with the appropriateness of a Scariest Golf Hole in Michigan compilation was too much to resist.
Now this isn’t a Hardest Holes in Michigan debate, just to be clear. That’s been done before, and honestly it doesn’t interest me much. A good challenging hole can still be fun, especially when the challenge is mostly mental. A lot of the usual suspects on those lists, though, are boring golf holes, often featuring shots over or between multiple water hazards, and/or offering little variety.
When I posited the Scariest Holes question to both my occasional co-author Brendan Aumann along with other members of the Fresh Coast Flock, I left the definition of scary open-ended. As a result, these scary holes are more likely to be Design Disasters candidates. The nightmare is in how someone built the golf hole and thought it was good. There are a few holes included, however, that are scary in how much they test your game or mess with your head.
These are just some of the holes that quickly come to mind, and it’s not meant to be an exhaustive list. Nor is it meant to disparage any of the listed courses. I always say that every course has its place and serves an audience, even if it happens to have one scary hole (or more). Scary holes just help us appreciate the good holes even more.
This list features both holes that I’ve played and nominated holes that I haven’t played. I will be sure to call out when they happen to be the latter.
The Monster at Brae Burn
This is the low-hanging fruit and top contender for so many reasons.
Just the idea of transforming a Wilfrid Reid hole into a 666-yard double dogleg par 5 is scary. Now put a blind water hazard in the landing area of the second shot, and have it be home to a snapping turtle. Extra scary. But scariest of all? Brae Burn promotes itself as “Home of the Monster” and uses the hole as its main marketing point.
18th Hole - University of Michigan GC
This one checks multiple boxes. First:


Going from the variability of a hole designed with a creek going through it to the all-or-nothing retention pond of today, one that often leads to layup shots of less than 50 yards, is ridiculous. That said, the hole is at least slightly better this year after a mix of both voluntary and involuntary (storms) tree removal.


Despite fewer trees, trying to come home with a 4 or even a 5 to secure a good score is terrifying. That is why I always prefer starting on the back 9 first and facing this hole as the 9th rather than the 18th.
6th hole - Fieldstone
Marsh hopping is one of my least favorite features in a golf design. Putting two in one terrible hole is unforgivable.
Nominee: 18th hole - Coyote
This looks like they incorporated the worst elements of the 6th at Fieldstone and the 18th at U of M into one spectacularly bad hole.
Scary Slices
4th hole - Plum Hollow
Ask most golfers about the scariest shot in golf, and perhaps they will say hitting over water, or to an island green, or perhaps to a fairway with water on both sides. To me that is nothing. If you want to rattle me, put the prospect of property damage anywhere within close proximity of a golf hole. The most terrifying example this summer was the 4th at Plum Hollow.
Below is a long par-4 with a fairway closely surrounded on both sides by trees, and 9 Mile Road running parallel just beyond the trees to the right. I would have nightmares about putting one on the road in the best of circumstances. In this summer’s round, I watched my playing partner pump one on to 9 Mile before I teed it up. You better believe when it was my turn I aimed for the next fairway over, the 6th, and ended up behind a tree between the two holes. I was perfectly happy with that result and my ensuing 50-yard punch shot back out to the fairway.
Nominee: Manistee G & CC (Multiple)
Look out if you are anywhere along this stretch of roads. There are no less then 3 different opportunities for the slicer to inflict some property damage.
Horrifying Hooks
1st hole - Rackham
I couldn’t forget about those fighting a snap hook off the tee. You must face your demons on the first shot of the day at Rackham, and the number of moving objects in play are among the highest you will find in any single shot.
Front 9 - Edgewood CC
It’s hard to match the risk of a tee ball landing on I-696. So Edgewood went for quantity over quality by presenting OB down the left of the entire front 9.
Don’t let anyone ever tell you that a course’s routing isn’t important.
2nd hole - Apple Mountain
A blast from my past at the course where I worked as a teenager, and one that offers a bit of both worlds. The 2nd hole often set the tone for the day. A tee shot that finds the fairway is all but assured a par at worst. But the water down the right is such a visually intimidating factor, it usually caused me to steer a ball into the trees and OB left. I’m sure I also blasted the occasional tee ball so far right that it cleared the water, but thankfully none of the housing was there back in my day.
6th hole (RIP) - Petoskey-Bay View
This hole posed such an interesting question. What if the risk of property damage was right in the middle of the hole?
Yes, that is a road in the landing area. Not a driveway, a regular road. You can’t see it from the tee, and you can’t see the tee from the road. It was a nightmare. Kind of hilarious, but not from the club’s perspective. They finally rerouted holes 6-8 in the past several years to eliminate this shot from the routing.
Just Incredibly Bad
14th hole - The Myth
To me this is the worst golf hole in the state, and I hope to never find one that is worse.
Tall trees left of the tee prevent most players from being able to hit anything more than about an 8 iron on the first shot. Should you be the rare specimen to have a high hook in your bag, good luck knowing whether or not the green is clear, or finding your ball for your next shot. For most humans, your iron shot will need to land in an area the size of a small green if you intend to have a look at the green in regulation. If you are a slicer, have fun trying to stay out of the parking lot.
6th at Hilltop
Oh where to even start? Maybe at the 29 second mark here, showing a green that gets very little sun and can’t hold a golf ball.
So many random trees. So much marsh hopping. I’m starting to rethink how I feel about the 14th at The Myth.
9th hole - Moose Ridge
I’ve written a lengthy piece in the past with my thoughts on Moose Ridge, so this won’t be a surprising inclusion. I even wrote about the hole in that article. It went a little something like this.
The hole plays from 183 to 191 from the back 3 tees, and is almost all carry to the green, covering a marsh and a steep ridge in front of the putting surface. The hole preview says anything right will “usually bounce onto the green”, but I’ve rarely seen that play work. Most shots to the right end up in the forest. Shots to the left tumble down the ridge into the marsh. On multiple occasions, when it is dry enough, I’ve scaled down that ridge and emerged with more than a dozen golf balls. It’s a popular place to miss.
For the average Detroit public golfer, a 175+ yard carry to a tight landing zone is a tough ask. The bailout, according to the hole preview, is past the green. Because of course, for most golfers who will struggle with landing a long iron in a tight window, a more reasonable strategy for them will be to try and hit a straight 200 yard shot, instead.
Simply put, there is one way to play this hole. Hit the shot. Or don’t, and take your double bogey.
Just Good and Challenging
16th hole - Diamond Springs
Back to the challenging variety of scary holes, the 16th at Diamond Springs confronts you with a series of decisions from tee to green. The Google aerial does a decent job of showing the topography, but in case of any confusion, that is a deep ravine that runs down the right side for nearly the length of the hole.
I attempted a conservative tee shot here but still ended up mere feet from tumbling down to a lost ball. I then avoided the ravine as much as possible in my subsequent shots, and paid for it later in having to deal with that greenside bunker.



It asks a lot of questions, and forces you to eventually challenge the ravine sooner or later.
Other Nominations
1st tee shot on last day of buddies trip
16th hole - Pilgrim’s Run
11th hole - Crystal Downs
18th hole - PohlCat
I’ve had pretty decent luck getting off of the tee on the last day of my annual buddies trip, but I have indeed seen some truly grotesque swings from others in the group.
The 16th at Pilgrim’s asks you to hit either a massively difficult tee shot, or defer the effort to the second shot. I will weigh in someday when I play it, but there is debate whether this hole is good and challenging, or just hard with few options.




I’m familiar with the difficulty of the 11th at Crystal despite not having played it. I made a rendition of this course in PGA 2K in the past, and normally recreating a course using LiDAR elevation data just requires a few slight touch ups to ensure it plays similar to real life in the game. The 11th at Crystal required a complete overhaul simply to keep balls on the green. I believe Tom Doak slightly tamed the slopes in the past to account for modern green speeds, but 3 and 4 putts are still common, I hear.
As for the PohlCat, I will leave Brendan with the parting word:
Seventeen is one of my favorite par 3’s, but then you go home on what is probably one of the worst eighteenth holes in the state. It’s like they decided they had to have seventeen where it is & then figured they’d make it work from there, but they definitely did not make it work. You have to either lay back or hit your drive from right to left or you’ll hit the clubhouse/be in the range. If you go too far left you’re dead or blocked out & the cart path cuts directly across the fairway to a rather uphill green. The closing stretch of 16-17-18 feels like 90’s golf at its finest and, while forced carries, target golf, and tree-lined holes may have been what Dan Pohl was used to on tour, it’s not what I want to play in my everyday round.
Feel free to leave your scariest holes in Michigan below.














The first 5 holes at Lochmoor have OB right the entire way. Seen guys be down two sleeves before making the turn.
The closing 3 holes at Radrick are played through progressively narrower tunnels of trees. Hit it here or die.
9th hole at Northville Hills (most of the holes there tbh).
12th hole at Lake Forest (7i off the tee with the potential to be blocked out by trees to either side of the tunnel you need to hit your 2nd shot through...and over a pond that cuts off your landing area).
3rd hole at Point O' Woods. Possibly the narrowest tunnel for an approach shot I've ever seen.
18th hole at Pheasant Run.
13th hole at Salem Hills.
11th hole at Treetops Signature (tunnels of trees are not my jam, especially on par 3's).
4th hole at Treetops Masterpiece (the old green was wonderful, the new one is not).
7th hole at Shanty Creek Legend.
The Chief.
Would nominate a couple from Indianwood New for either property risk, OB or both. 7 with the house very near the outer corner of the dogleg, and lilypadding on 18/2 come to mind. Could also throw in tee shot on 13 going directly over 4.